Head to head

M4A1 Sherman vs Matilda Black Prince

Two vehicles side by side — expected values from the XVM reference, measured values from the stored profiles.

First tank
M4A1 Sherman
M4A1 Sherman
Tier V Medium Tank USA
vs
Second tank
Matilda Black Prince
Matilda Black Prince
Tier V Medium Tank Great Britain

Loading list…

No tank found

Loading list…

No tank found

Swap
2 : 5

Overall picture

Matilda Black Prince leads in 5 of 7 comparable metrics.

Only mutually independent values are counted: win rate, average WN8 and the five expected values. Battle count measures popularity rather than strength, and the MoE thresholds are arithmetically the same figure as average damage — both stay out.

Strength profile

Five axes side by side

Each axis is scaled to the range of the tiers involved: the outer edge is the best value of the tier, the centre the weakest. The shape therefore shows where a vehicle stands among its peers — not merely which of the two numbers is larger.

Damage Kills Spotting Defence Win rate
M4A1 Sherman Matilda Black Prince

Measured stats

Measured, not estimated

54.90 %

Win rate

1.3 % difference

55.64 %
1,678

Avg. WN8

13.4 % difference

1,938
34,676

Battles

83.8 % difference

5,606

Expected values per battle

XVM reference

514

Avg. damage

4.7 % difference

539
1.06

Avg. kills

2.2 % difference

1.08
1.38

Avg. spotted

42.7 % difference

0.79
1.03

Avg. defence

28.0 % difference

1.43
54.79 %

Exp. win rate

0.8 % difference

54.38 %

Marks of Excellence

Lower is better

The bar shows the combined damage required for each mark of excellence. All six bars share one scale — the shorter one marks the vehicle on which the mark is easier to earn.

1 Mark
M4A1 Sherman 847
Matilda Black Prince 889
2 Marks
M4A1 Sherman 1,233
Matilda Black Prince 1,293
3 Marks
M4A1 Sherman 1,592
Matilda Black Prince 1,671

Approximation based on WN8 expected values — not an official Wargaming figure.

Standing within the tier

Percentile among all vehicles of the same tier

Both vehicles are measured against their own tier, not against each other. That keeps a cross-tier comparison readable: the percentage states which share of the vehicle’s own tier scores worse.

M4A1 Sherman Tier V
Win rate Rank 36 of 87

Better than 59 % of the tier

Avg. WN8 Rank 44 of 81

Better than 46 % of the tier

Matilda Black Prince Tier V
Win rate Rank 26 of 87

Better than 71 % of the tier

Avg. WN8 Rank 26 of 81

Better than 69 % of the tier

Best players in this duel

The three best stored profiles per vehicle

From the stored profiles, minimum 50 battles on this vehicle. Updated daily.

M4A1 Sherman
Matilda Black Prince

The advantage is highlighted in the colour of its side — for the MoE thresholds that is the lower value. Expected values are reference figures for the WN8 calculation, not vehicle statistics: they state what an average player achieves in this tank.

M4A1 Sherman data sheet Matilda Black Prince data sheet